How Many Shops Are You Competing With on Etsy? (2026)
Short answer: between about 29 and 91 shops, depending entirely on the phrase — and the count matters more than the listing count, because listings tell you how much has been made while shops tell you how many rivals you actually have. "How much competition is there?" is the right question asked with the wrong number. Here is what we measured across eleven live Etsy searches, including one widely-shown competition metric that turns out to be the same in every niche.
Listings are the number everyone quotes. Shops are the number that matters.
Search anything on Etsy and you are told how many listings matched — often tens of thousands. It feels like the measure of competition, and it mostly is not. Twenty thousand listings held by a few hundred shops is a different market from twenty thousand held by fifteen thousand shops, and only the second one has room in it.
What you are actually competing against is shops: each one with its own review history, its own sales velocity, and its own position in Etsy's ranking. A seller making beaded earrings, a seller printing tote bags and a seller sewing linen aprons all face the same question — how many other sellers already hold the phrase I want?
What we measured
We ran eleven live Etsy searches across unrelated categories and counted the distinct shops holding the results. The spread was wide:
- 29 shops at the concentrated end — a phrase a small group of sellers owns.
- 91 shops at the fragmented end — results spread thin across many sellers.
- Everything in between: 55, 67, 69, 70, 72, 79, 85.
That range is the point. The shop count genuinely distinguishes one keyword from another, which is exactly what you need from a competition signal.
The metric that looks useful and is not
Several keyword tools show you something like "the biggest shop holds N of the top results". It reads like a dominance score. We measured it in the same eleven searches, and every single term that returned a full page of results gave the same answer: the largest shop held three, and the top three shops held nine.
Three, in every niche we tried — digital planners, jewellery, pet accessories, print-on-demand mugs. Only the terms whose entire market was thinner than a single page of results moved the number at all.
A number that is identical everywhere cannot tell two keywords apart. It is not wrong, it is just not information — which is why we show the shop count instead, and why we are telling you about the one we decided not to ship.
How to read a shop count
The intuition most sellers have is backwards, so it is worth stating plainly:
- A LOW shop count is usually bad news for a new seller. Few shops holding the results means established sellers own the phrase, and they own it with review history you do not have yet.
- A HIGH shop count is usually the opportunity. Results spread across many sellers means no one has locked it down, and a well-made listing can surface.
- Read it next to demand. A phrase nobody searches for will have a low shop count because nobody bothered. Spread plus genuine search volume is the combination worth chasing.
What this does not tell you
Being straight about the limits, because a confident number with a hidden caveat is worse than no number:
- It is a sample of one page. The count comes from the results Etsy returns for that search, not from every listing in the category.
- It does not measure quality. Ninety shops of excellent listings is harder than thirty mediocre ones, and no count can see that.
- It says nothing about what any shop earns. We do not estimate other sellers' sales or revenue, because those figures are not knowable from outside and the tools that show them are modelling, not measuring.
Find the number for your own keyword
Our free Etsy keyword tool reports the shop count for any phrase, with no account and nothing to install. It shows the price spread across those listings and the tags they have in common, and every figure is labelled with where it came from — so you can always tell a number read from Etsy from one we calculated.
If you want the same read on a listing that already exists, the free listing audit grades one against the published rubric, and will tell you when a number cannot be trusted rather than showing it anyway.